The Everton Collection includes a wide range of fans' memorabilia, from autographs, badges and calendars to pennants, posters and teapots.

With over 1,250 cigarette cards and trading cards, the Collection has some of the earliest football collectors cards in the world, dating back to 1897. Dixie Dean appears on more cigarette cards than any other British footballer and appears on 30 cards in the Collection. Other items of fans' memorabilia include bobble hats and rosettes.